Treatment of Macular Degeneration with Macugen, Lucentis and Avastin

Most of the treatments that are available now and and currently being studied are aimed at stopping the neovascular (or wet) form of AMD. The only known treatment for preventing the progression of Dry Macular Degeneration is Nutritional Supplements, such as VisiVite.

In June 2006, the drug ranibizumab (Lucentis) has been approved by the FDA for use in the treatment of AMD.

Ranibizumab has been shown to halt the progression of the disease in most patients receiving the treatment. Unlike previous treatments, a significant majority (70%) receiving ranibizumab had an improvement in vision of at least 1 letter. Up to 40% of patients had a significant vision increase of 3 lines or more. In addition, up to 50% had a vision of 20/40 or better after 12 months of treatment. This is significant as 20/40 is commonly seen as the vision at which a person can still drive a car. Ranibizumab was the first therapy to show a statistically significant improvement in patient reported outcomes. Ranibizumab is given as an injection into the eye. The initial studies required an injection every 4 weeks for 2 years.

Bevacizumab (Avastin), a drug approved for use in colon cancer, has been used by ophthalmologists in the treatment of wet macular degeneration.

Bevacizumab and ranibizumab were developed for the same monoclonal antibody parent. However, ranibizumab has been affinity matured 140x and is a much smaller molecule than bevazicumab. Being smaller allows ranibizumab to penetrate all layers of the retina and also to clear faster systemically from the eye. Doubts about whether bevacizumab can penetrate the layers of the retina led to the development of ranibizumab. There are also concerns about the safety of bevacizumab as it known to have significant systemic effects.

Before Lucentis was available, bevacizumab was widely used by ophthalmologists who treat macular degeneration. Some of their experiences with large numbers of patients with relatively short follow-up times were recently published. No randomized controlled clinical trial with systematic safety data collection has been performed to validate its efficacy and safety with same certainty as ranibizumab.

Bevacizumab, when administered at the usual cancer treatment doses, has been shown to cause systemic adverse effects. The most common adverse effect was hypertension. There is a continued interest as the bevacizumab for use in the eye can be obtained for about 30-50 dollars per dose, compared to 2,000 dollars per dose for ranibizumab. One concern is that bevacizumab is aliquotted out by compounding pharmacies from a single use vial of bevacizumab. This may lead to degradation and impurities within the product. Following the recommended protocol for ranibizumab costs about $50,000 per eye over two years.

The National Eye Institute is planning a head-to-head ranibizumab vs. bevacizumab, randomized, controlled clinical trial for treatment of macular degeneration. Currently more than 50% of retinal specialists use bevacizumab as the first line drug (ACRS Practice Patterns Survey).

Pegabtanib (Macugen) was approved in 2004 for treatment of neovascular AMD. It targets certain forms of VEGF molecules and is injected directly into the eye like ranibizumab or bevacizumab. Although this was shown to decrease the risk of vision loss significantly compared to no treatment,
it is felt to be relatively ineffective compared to the newer treatments.

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) with verteporfin (Visudyne) had been the treatment of choice for neovascular AMD until recently. This was the first treatment shown to decrease the chance of severe vision loss in 2 years in patients with neovascular AMD without first causing immediate vision loss at the time of the treatment. A photosensitive dye with affinity for the abnormal blood vessels are first injected through the veins. A low-energy activating laser is then directed toward the abnormal blood vessels, causing selective damage to those blood vessels.
This has also fallen out of favor as newer, more effective treatments became available.

Direct laser treatment for neovascular AMD was shown to decrease the chance of profound vision loss at 2 years in patients with neovascular AMD but it is seldom used as the treatment itself causes significant vision loss immediately. Infrequently, abnormal blood vessels outside of the center part of the macula are detected. Direct laser treatment can be an effective way to treat these patients with acceptable morbidity.

Other drugs that are currently under investigation include: anecortave (Retaane), squalamine (Evizon) and siRNA. Second generation antisense oligonucleotides iCo-007 targeting the Raf-1 kinase are also under investigation as a target for broad inhibition of multiple pro-angiogenic signals. Radiation therapy (brachytherapy) and rheopheresis are also being evaluated for wet macular degeneration.

None of the drugs or laser treatment can restore vision to patients that have already suffered permanent damage to the photoreceptors or retinal pigmented epithelial cells due to advanced forms of AMD. Stem cells are currently being studied as a potential solution to this problem.

OT-551 eyedrop is currently being evaluated in an National Eye Institute-sponsored trial as a treatment for the dry form of AMD (the drug is already under investigation as a treatment for cataracts).

Send Page to Friend

Eye Vitamins

Senior Eye Health

Other AMD Resources

  • "I just wanted to say that VisiVite.com is amazing!" ~Johnny, OH